Woman happy but confused about ETFs

WTF is an ETF?

Excuse my French but more of us out there know what the common expression of frustration WTF means than what an ETF is. I’m keeping this PG here and will let you navigate to Urban Dictionary if would like to learn what WTF means.

I could go on an on about the jargon in the investment industry but let’s start with this term and break down the who, what, when and why of ETFs.


So What is an ETF Anyway?

An ETF stands for exchange-traded fund. It is a type of security you can invest in.

An Exchange-Traded Fund, is like a pre-packed grocery basket at the store. Imagine walking into a market and instead of buying individual ingredients, you grab a curated basket filled with the best produce, carbs, proteins and spices. No wandering around the grocery trying to decide if you’ve made the right choices for your meal. You take it home and can cook everything in under 30 minutes. Voila!

ETF is an Exchange Traded Fund

An ETF works similarly but with investments—it bundles together a collection of stocks, bonds, or other assets into one easy-to-access “basket” that you can buy and sell on the stock market. If you understand the methodology of how the ETF is built and the underlying assets (or ingredients), you don’t have to wander around the internet trolling for the best investments and falling for clickbait on “how to get rich quick”.

Comparing a grocery basket to an ETF holding

ETFs are a tool in your toolbox when you are deciding how and where to invest. The beauty is in the simplicity – you may be invested in the Dimensional US Small Cap ETF (DFAS) fund and see one line item in your portfolio. Under the hood, the fund is actually invested in over 2,000 small companies!

Having a well-diversified portfolio may help reduce risk while providing steady growth over time for investors. You invest WITH an ETF, you are not invested IN exchange-traded funds. In the example above, you are invested in small US companies with an ETF as the chosen tool to access that market and those companies.

It’s important to think about what’s inside that basket—different ETFs track different sectors, themes, countries, or asset types. The name of the ETF can sometimes give you a good idea of what type of underlying holdings are included but it’s important to do your own research and educate yourself to make sure you are investing your hard-earned dollars the way you’d like to.


How did ETFs come to market?

Let me take you back to the 1990s—shoulder pads were out and the internet was in. Investors had recovered from the stock market crash of 1987 known affectionally as “Black Monday”. This was the sharpest downturn since the Great Depression. Investors, understandably, were looking for something new. They wanted an easier, more efficient way to invest without constantly picking and managing individual stocks.

First came electronic trading in the 1980s, then an Index Participation Shares option in 1989 that was created as a proxy for the S&P 500. This was successfully challenged in the courts and sales of this product were halted. Our northern neighbor, Canada, had the first ETF ever in 1990.

The US followed shortly with its own in 1993. Nicknamed “Spider”, it was the SPDR S&P 500 ETF. Its purpose was to correspond generally to the performance of the S&P 500 Index, all bundled together in one neat package that traded on the stock market like a single stock. Shoutout to lady boss Kathleen Moriarty who was the attorney instrumental in helping develop SPY along with 3 other credited team members. At the time this was revolutionary. The SPDR is still around today and has had an impressive track record.

woman exploring Mars like environment in a space suit

Over the years, ETFs evolved into a powerhouse tool for investors and have made investing more accessible. By the early 2000s, investors could choose from ETFs tracking almost anything from VICE stocks to banking on being the first to ride the UFO wave to investing success.

While over 90% of ETFs remain passively managed, there are even actively managed ETFs available now. As of October 2024, there are over 3,500 ETFs in the US-traded markets.


Why Should I Use ETFs to Invest?

Although Exchange-Traded Funds have been around for several decades, they have gained even greater popularity the last several years. In fact, investors added $1.1 trillion into US ETFs in 2024.

So what are reasons why you may reach for an ETF in your investment ‘toolbox’ over other options?

  • Cost Effective Option

Compared to mutual funds, ETFs typically have lower expense ratios. This is in part because most ETFs are passively managed. The underlying fund managers may follow an index and specific rules to choose as well as buy and sell the underlying investments in passively managed funds. ETFs typically do not have to maintain cash reserves or accommodate redemptions (more on this below) like mutual funds.

But even between two passively managed funds, ETFs may still be lower than a similar mutual fund investment option. Take VOO and VFAIX for example. These are tickers or shortened fund names for two popular Vanguard funds.

Fund NameVanguard S&P 500 ETFVanguard 500 Index Fund Admiral Shares
TickerVOOVFIAX
Expense Ratio0.03%0.04%
Source: Vanguard.com – Fact Sheets as of 12/31/2024

While the two funds have similar short-term and long-term returns, the expenses ratio for VOO is slightly lower than the mutual fund option VFIAX. This can add up over time; especially for investors with a long time horizon.

  • Tax Efficient Option

ETFs are seen as a more tax-efficient option over mutual funds in part because investors generally only realize capital gains when they sell their own ETF shares for a gain. ETFs use ‘in-kind’ creation and redemption process. This process allows ETFs to pass securities to authorized participants without triggering taxable events for investors, helping to minimize unwanted capital gains. You are essentially buying from another investor instead of the fund manager as the intermediary.

This is in contrast to mutual funds where the manager of the fund will pass along or pass out the annual gains before year-end in the form of capital gains distributions. Since ETFs are generally passively managed, they have also have lower turnover which means fewer trades which means less taxable impact – woo hoo!

  • Trading Flexibility

The last benefit for ETFs over mutual funds is the flexibility when trading. ETFs trade throughout the day unlike mutual funds which are only bought or sold at the END of the trading day and give one net asset value or closing price per day. ETFs are priced in real-time throughout the trading day, giving you flexibility to buy and sell when the moment feels right.

This price transparency isn’t the only transparency benefit of ETFs. Holdings are generally published online daily. And while mutual funds have restrictions on frequent trading, ETFs do not.

Be careful with this flexibility though. Just because your ETFs trade more like stocks than mutual funds doesn’t mean you should tinker with your portfolio more often. This typically isn’t a long-term investment strategy. It’s always important to consider how your funds and trades fit within your overall strategy and ensure you aren’t making an emotional decision when investing.

Newspaper trading prices for mutual funds - end of day pricing

Because of all of these benefits, I anticipate that ETFs will continue to grow in popularity and are an important resource for all investors – those just getting started and experienced investors alike.


Conclusion

There ya go – a little French, a little finance jargon and maybe a little street cred if you went too far down the WTF rabbit hole on Urban Dictionary.

At Zestiny Wealth, we believe in simplifying the complex and helping you take charge of your financial future without the jargon. ETFs are just one piece of your investment puzzle and understanding what they are and where they came from helps you take charge confidently of your own financial future.

So, what’s in your investment basket? Let’s figure it out together and chat when you are ready to learn more. Coffee’s on me!